Magnanimous in Victory, Gracious in Defeat

Donald Trump has won the election and will be the next president of the United States.  Some people reading this will cheer, thump their chests and know they were right.  Others will feel deep sorrow and loss.   Some feel overwhelming fear.trump_hillary17-620x412

Our country has been through a social war.  This war has pitted friends and family against each other.  This fight has opened a huge divide between otherwise loving and considerate people.   Both sides in this war have felt attacked and made wrong.  It has become vicious and hurtful.   We have lost sight of when or how the war started, but continue to fight even after one side has claimed victory.

When it was looking good for the Blue team, the Red team was proposing revolution and anarchy.  Now that the Blue team lost, some are making similar noises.  Both sides are literally scared to death of the prospect of living in the world they see on the other side.

Each side is using what it can to show the other how stupid they are.  Each side forgetting civility … which is understandable in war.   We have been at war… the 2016 civil war.   Both the Red and the Blue are afraid of their very lives being taken from them.  Both feel that they don’t have a place in the other’s world.  Yes, Red is afraid of losing their lives, their jobs, their freedoms… just like Blue is afraid of being targeted for not being a straight white male (I have clearly oversimplified the issues here… issues aside, both sides are scared to death.)

Now here is the thing.  It isn’t likely that any time soon, one side will suddenly realize that the other side was right.  It isn’t going to happen.  People are not going to change ‘sides’ in this fight.  Think about that.   We will never convince the other 1/2 of our country that our reality is superior to theirs.   They will NOT see it your way.  Otherwise good, loving people *seem* to be mean and ignorant … delusional at best.  “Seem” is an important word in that last sentence — because it isn’t true, it just looks that way from where YOU are standing.

So what does that mean?   Are we destined to have our country, communities and families divided?  Do we have to raise our own personal walls against each other — restrict our exposure to only those that see the world as we do?   Do we need to protest, strike, fight some more, until everyone sees eye to eye?   It is NOT going to happen… when fear rises, when survival drives us, we will climb over each other to save ourselves.  Make no mistake, that is what has been happening.  When fear drives us, we protect what we are afraid of losing at all costs.  YES WE DO.

When I first started couples counseling, my marriage was in a desperate state… I was in a desperate state.  Years of fighting had generated so many injuries and grievances that we never looked underneath the injuries to see what the core issues were.  By focusing solely on our grievances all we did was create more damage.  We had two completely different worlds of suffering that our partners couldn’t enter.  We were both powerless to create the life we wanted, and resorted to force in an attempt to get it.  Learning how to fight without hurting each other was a relationship saving skill!

We don’t know how to do that.  When we can’t have our way, we toss trash around … and that trash is added to our disagreements.   We stop looking at issues and start focusing on trash.  We fight dirty.  We call other people’s character into question.  We gathered evidence to prove how wrong the other was — we both had plenty of evidence.  But that is the cost of war.  There are always atrocities on both sides.  We are always justified because we didn’t start it … right?

But look, that kind of fighting never leads to a healthy union.  It’s time to stop fighting dirty.  It’s time to stop using force because we feel powerless and afraid.

BTW, when our constitution was created by our founding parents, they didn’t agree with each other.  They fought a great deal about how the country should look and how it should work.  There wasn’t some aha moment when they all came together and crapped out our constitution.  No, the constitution exists as proof that people can have serious disagreements and still create a more perfect union.

Whether you are on the Blue team or the Red team, we need to stop tossing trash.  It’s time to bring civility back … regardless of what the other side is doing.  We are not in charge of what the media does, but we are in charge of the trash we create or share into the world.

For many, the election feels like the end of possibilities and the end of the world as you know it.  But consider that sometimes, we need to break something so that it can come back together in a way more perfect than it was before.   Believe me, I didn’t vote to break the system — but perhaps now that it has been shattered, we can really fix what we all knew was broken all along.

It is time to stop focusing on what we are afraid of.  It is time to accept the mess we have all created in being at war with each other.  It’s time to put the last 2 years behind and move on to something better than was possible before.   One team’s way isn’t better than the others’.   But if we don’t find win-win solutions then we will be destined to have lose-lose ones.

Neither the Red team nor the Blue team will get what they want without cooperation from the other team.   None of us will get what we want without appreciation of the diversity of our partners and the people in our communities and country.   We can’t get what we want by force.

I am not suggesting that we fall asleep and hope for the best.  Sleeping is what put us all in this mess in the first place.  But we must stop proving how wrong the others are.   We must start seeing how we are the same — while of course, standing for what is right.

Standing for what is right doesn’t mean starting a fight for what is right.  Standing for what is right doesn’t mean threatening the other side to cross some line — provoking what we all don’t want.  Standing for what is right means we are alert and respond when called on.  Our fight isn’t with each other, but with the system which isn’t serving us.  How to fix that system is a conversation that can happen only when we are all dedicated to doing the hard patient work of community building rather than easy character assassinations.  Standing for what is right requires a kind of strength, patience and openness to possibilities.

But first we need to move off of our war footing with each other, and move towards growth, prosperity, possibility and mostly civility.   Without civility, we will never find our way out of the darkness.

Red won the election.  But so far, we are all losers.  We have all lost friends.  We have all lost connection.   In fighting against each other, we are all less safe.  We have all lost some of our humanity.

It’s time to stop fighting friends, neighbors and family.  It’s time to fight for humanity.  It’s time to listen more than shouting.  It’s time to accept others even if they don’t accept you.   It’s time to heal and expect good things, and work towards them.   It’s time to stop catastrophizing  and worrying about a future that isn’t here yet.

Please pledge to stop spreading hate.  Stop protesting or gloating.  Stop fighting dirty.  Stop proving how right you are.   Pledge to build something rather than tearing things down.   Let your social media be an ambassador for good not fear and hate.

Love and blessings to you, to your families, to our country and to the world!



For those in mourning or loss, please take your time.  This article isn’t intended to push you towards healing or resolution.  We simply need to stop trashing the place where we live…

6 Responses to Magnanimous in Victory, Gracious in Defeat

  1. Cece says:

    Beautiful!… As Always, Very Well Stated. Thanks!

  2. Ellis Traub says:

    Our system has given us a pretty good quality of life.

    Compared with those who, in the past, gave their thought, energy, and their lives to create that system, we haven’t done—or had to do—all that much to preserve

    If we’re unhappy with what that system gave us for a president, Isn’t it in our best interest to to do all we can to make him a better one rather than to condemn and destroy the system that put him there?

    David, your words are gracious and in keeping with who you are..

  3. Mitch Greenberg says:

    Perfectly stated. Thank you for this.

  4. Stephen Kattell says:

    Thanks David. That’s good stuff!

  5. Bob McGoffin says:

    Well stated , David! We all need input ( in put)into the kind of government we want, but we must respect opposing positions and look to find how their views are valid, because they are,always! Just like how we feel about a particular issue, the other person feels a differently. Let us all realize that we are all part of this great country and if we don’t give respect to another part of this great country, then YOU are disrespecting YOUR country and that is not great for our great country!
    To all of you that are grieving your losses I hope you find peace and comfort soon. Remember that God loves each and every one of us equally and without limits. My hope is that we can all work together to compromise on the issues that we can’t agree on and work towards a solution to the many problems this has.
    To all of you that are celebrating our victory?. Remember how you have felt during the last four years when your ideas were not listened to and your rights were under attack, that is exactly how the other half of this nation is feeling right now! Let us calm the rhetoric and reach out a gentle hand to our brothers and sisters who are feeling pain. Remember God loves them the same as He loves us!
    Together we can Love this country Stronger!

  6. Great blog post David. I choose to be peaceful and in action. I vow to make a difference in the way I can regardless of circumstances. I am bigger than my circumstances.

    “Sometimes the dark forces win. Sometimes the outcome is dreadful. But all our practices in peace and grace and equanimity and courage are for TIMES LIKE THESE — for times when you do not get the outcome that you want. This is when it matters. When the shit goes down, and the shit goes wrong, and when the shit gets real — that’s when the shit gets interesting. That’s when the test comes: Who will you be now? Right now. Right this moment. Because that’s the only part that is up to you.”
    – Elizabeth Gilbert

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *